I wrote this post a while ago on another website but here it is again. I’m due for an updated form, but this will do for now. This link will give you an idea what happened in 2014 on Folksy. It gives a really nice summary of what has sold etc. There’s some nice stats here on Etsy too. When I get the chance I’ll aim to summarise everything for y’all!
“I’ve been considering selling on Etsy (www.etsy.com) and/or selling on Folksy (www.folksy.co.uk) for a while. For those of you who haven’t heard of these websites before they are both massive ‘handmade marketplaces’ where you can buy loads of different handmade goods from textiles to ceramics to clocks and from very beautiful items to well, rather weird and specialised. The main differences between the two are that Etsy is an American-based but very international site with sellers from all over the world whereas Folksy is a younger, primarily UK-based, spin-off of the same site. There are other sites like Etsy or Folksy including Misi, notonthehighstreet and DaWanda but I haven’t included these just yet.
What I have attempted to do here is create a quick guide using some numbers I’ve gleaned from across the internet (mainly from their press pages) in order to help you make a decision if you would like to sell on one.
* – I used today’s exchange rate of $1=£0.6577. Listing prices will vary according to this and what rate your credit card gives you.
** – please also note that banks may charge you extra because of the conversion of dollars to pounds and these fees may be significant.
Now like any good scientist lets discuss these results. Firstly you will notice that I have averaged everything. It is likely that some shops and/or products receive more hits/sell more than others. But once you look at the overall averages, Etsy is looking much more favourable:
1. You are likely to make 4x as much money, as an average.
2. You will receive 5x as many views in your shop and nearly 3x as many product views, as an average.
As a whole Etsy makes 346x more money than Folksy and has 131x as many unique visitors per month. But these are of course spread across many more shops and products – your product really does have to stand out to make it amongst the 18 million other products for sale. On the otherhand Etsy is a global website whereas Folksy is more UK-based. Therefore you may reach a much bigger market but if you are selling on Etsy, to make the most benefit from the site, I suspect you would need to make sure you are happy to sell and post your product globally.
It is interesting to note that as a proportion Folksy has a much higher proportion of unique visitors compared to total visits – does this mean that more people go back to Etsy after their first visit, or are more people learning about the presence of Folksy? However these figures do not tell the whole story so it is important that we look at some other facts. The key point here is that Folksy is a handmade and craft supplies marketplace whereas on Etsy you can also sell vintage. Those of you in the know, know that vintage is a huge market right now. As of today out of 20,317,078 listings on Etsy (wow), 3,392,646 are listed as vintage – that means more than 16% of items are vintage. Craft supplies make up nearly 15%. In comparison Folksy currently has 145,855 items listed and just 5% of those are craft supplies. The moral of the story? It is likely, although I don’t have figures, that sales other than handmade goods make up a good proportion of Etsy’s sales.
I do love this number crunching stuff.
Some other minor differences; Folksy uses PayPal, Etsy uses a credit card (initially) or you can then link your account to PayPal. Bills for Folksy are on the 1st of the month, Etsy on the 15th.The final thing that I have to end on is costs. Unless you are listing about 350 items a year, per item, Etsy is cheaper and their commission is a lot less when you manage to sell the item. Remember that PayPal also charges you but it will be the same whichever site you choose. This is currently 20p + 3.4%. As another point which I didn’t include initially and have now added in at a later date is that banks may charge you a fee to convert your precious sales from dollars into pounds and vice versa – so be warned as these costs may be significant.
So my advice? Well having never sold or even tried to sell anything on either site, I am going only from my figures above. If it has to be one, I would say Etsy. But I would suggest trying both for the four months for 10-20 items and go from there. It could be that sales in Folksy are spread across more sellers. Or you might find it hard to get noticed in Etsy while it could be easier in Folksy. So Folksy or Etsy? There’s only one way to find out….
The actual final thing I want to end on, is I want to hear from you – have you tried one or the other? Did you find one more successful? Maybe I’ll add a second blog on crafter’s experiences on these two sites. Please share this page!”